Holding trying to fight Haaland early on. He won that free kick but I don’t think he’ll win that war if he tries to simply out muscle him all game

Great hit from Tomiyasu - saved - good build up from Trossard

Trossard looking sharp early on

We are right in this.

Good man Turner. That could have gone wrong and badly.

Our keeper did well to come out for that defensive miss but I keep wondering if he will end up costing us in such a high level game?

One thing for sure, and this is with subs mind you, we look like we belong and we are worthy of the accolades thus far.

Trossard looking very aware defensively. Cutting out lots of options for City to progress. I”m impressed so far.

Unsurprisingly not too shabby on the offensive either.

Holding has done excellently against Haaland so far

Yes, and with Rico Lewis inverting a lot Trossard is finding himself up against Stones in right back areas. I think he can win that battle

Close effort from de Bruyne - but that’s the first time I’ve noticed de Bruyne in the game at all

Can't allow looks like that at goal.

Liking Trossard

Tierney, while solid defensively is a straight forward, "old fashioned" fullback in his play, not the 1 touch type that we get with Zinchenko and currently the play we do. I can see why for his exclusion.

Holding bullies Haaland again, Arsenal on a good break but ref stops it for a head injury to Haaland following a bit of a whack from Holding

Referee stopped play at the wrong time.

Charlie George and mud...Derby County 2-2?....spent all afternoon being gobbed at by derby pop-side muppets. Replay during the power cuts and then second replay and win at Filbert street...those were the days! - Looking good so far today!

….happy days.

The size of City at the back compared to our attackers is visibly giants vs men, size wise.

Holding panicked a bit and got booked this will have a big impact.

Get through to the half even and that's doing well. I don't think we have enough talent on the pitch to win it if I'm honest. If we can sneak a goal and make them chase the game. If they score first, we'll have to make changes to equalize maybe.

Very encouraging to see us competing so well with 6 changes. Holding on a yellow against Haaland is the big worry going forward.

You’re dead right.

Recently we’ve turned up to these big games and got our arses kicked. Now we look like the real deal, even with a sub-optimal line up.

At full strength, I think arguably both Spanish giants, PSG and Bayern Munich and City maybe are better than us. I don't see anyone in Serie A better.

What a good first half performance.
Trossard looks like he is going to be very good signing.
Really impressed by him.
We have looked solid and threatening despite only having 6 of out starting from the weekend while city have 9 starting from the weekend.
Holding needs to be subbed off.
He'll get himself sent off

We did very well in the first half. Showed that we are not afraid of Man City. Keep it going!

We are frustrating Haaland by shadowing him. So far Mikel's tactics, the booking on Holding notwithstanding, is doing well, but its touch and go. He's good for a goal or two. Trossard trying a bit too much to impress taking on players, even when he's doubled up on, when he's better off laying off the ball. I'm being a bit harsh and I understand it. He's a wonderful addition though.

Very ballsy of us with all those changes to press them all the way up to the keeper. But its working.

Holding seems to want to wrestle him at every juncture.

We are now a team that impose ourselves despite the opponent. And we must do so when we start against Everton. Do not be complacent and seize the initiative from the get go.

Big question is do we keep Holding on the pitch? The battle with Haaland will be a physical one and there will be a lot of tugging, pushing and such and I can see the referee calling something 50/50 between them in City's favor.

All season there’s been a sense of yes you’re doing well but just wait until you play…..

Well, the only team left has been Man City. And, irrespective of this Cup result, we are doing a great job.

He could just switch Tom and him.

Question answered. Makes sense.

Come on Lakonga. Now’s your chance.

Saliba on for Holding - makes sense because of the yellow card

Lokonga also on for Partey. Hopefully that’s pre planned or at worst just a precaution. Otherwise any CM we want just added £20m to their price

Hope Partey's ok.........

Interesting, Saliba I can see for the change. We'll see how this pans out. We made a statement the first half though. Especially playing away.

Thomas didn’t get injured did he Please no